« Selective Sociality and Social Villages | Main | YouTube New Interface and Social Interaction Design Santiy Check »
Denning and Yaholkovsky on Real Collaboration
The latest edition of the Communications of the ACM (Volume 51, Issue 4 - April 2008) includes an article on Getting to "we", which starts off by pointing out the misuse and mis-understanding of the term collaboration as well as the over use of the practice of collaboration when it is not proper for the need. The authors Peter Denning and Peter Yaholkovsky break down the tools needed for various knowledge needs into four categories: 1) Information sharing; 2) Coordination; 3) Cooperation; and Collaboration. The authors define collaboration as:
Collaboration generally means working together synergistically. If your work requires support and agreement of others before you can take action, you are collaborating.
The article continues on to point out that collaboration is often not the first choice of tools we should reach for, as gathering information, understanding, and working through options is really needed in order to get to the stages of agreement. Their article digs deeply into the resolving "messy problems" through proper collaboration methods. To note, the wiki - the usual darling of collaboration - is included in their "cooperation" examples and not Collaboration. Most of the tools many businesses consider in collaboration tools are in the lowest level, which is "information sharing". But, workflow managment falls into the coordination bucket.
This is one of the better breakdowns of tool sets I have seen. The groupings make a lot of sense and their framing of collaboration to take care of the messiest problems is rather good, but most of the tools and services that are considered to be collaborations tools do not even come close to that description or to the capabilities required.
April 9, 2008 in Applications, Community, Enterprise, Information Architecture, Knowledge Management, Local InfoCloud, Social Software, Technology, Web | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83455b30d69e200e551d395e08834
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Denning and Yaholkovsky on Real Collaboration:
» Collaboration thread in CACM for April 2008 from Knowledge Jolt with Jack
There is an interesting pair of articles that focus on collaboration in the April 2008 Communications of the ACM. And one of them leads to even more interesting stuff. [Read More]
Tracked on Apr 14, 2008 1:24:22 AM
